Wednesday, December 16, 2009

Market Interest Rates Need to Tell the Truth, or Why Federal Reserve Policy Tells Lies by Richard M. Ebeling

On December 16, 2009, the Federal Reserve Open Market Committee announced that it was planning to maintain a Federal Funds rate between zero and a quarter of a percentage point. The Committee said that it would keep interest rates “exceptionally low” for an “extended period.”

Arguing that there was no reason to fear significant price inflation for the foreseeable future, the Open Market Committee also told that it was continuing to inject more Federal Reserve-created money into the financial markets as it finishes buying up by the end of March 2010 a total of more than $1.5 trillion in mortgage-backed securities and related debt held on the books of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Virtually all commentaries about the Fed’s announced policies focus on whether it is too soon for the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates given the state of the economy, or whether the Fed should already be raising interest rates to prevent future price inflation.

What is being ignored is the more fundamental question of whether the Fed should be attempting to set or influence interest rates in the market. The presumption is that it is both legitimate and desirable for central banks to manipulate a market price, in this case the price of borrowing and lending. The only disagreements among the analysts and commentators are over whether the central banks should keep interest rates low or nudge them up and if so by how much.

Market-Based Interest Rates have Work to Do

In the free market, interest rates perform the same functions as all other prices: to provide information to market participants; to serve as an incentive mechanism for buyers and sellers; and to bring market supply and demand into balance. Market prices convey information about what goods consumers want and what it would cost for producers to bring those goods to the market. Market prices serve as an incentive for producers to supply more of a good when the price goes up and to supply less when the price goes down; similarly, a lower or higher price influences consumers to buy more or less of a good. And finally, the movement of a market price, by stimulating more or less demand and supply, tends to bring the two sides of the market into balance.

Market rates of interest balance the actions and decisions of borrowers (investors) and lenders (savers) just as the prices of shoes, hats, or bananas balance the activities of the suppliers and demanders of those goods. This assures, on the one hand, that resources that are not being used to produce consumer goods are available for future-oriented investment, and, on the other, that investment doesn’t outrun the saved resources available to support it.

Interest rates higher than those that would balance saving with investment stimulate more saving than investors are willing to borrow, and interest rates below that balancing point stimulate more borrowing than savers are willing to supply.

There is one crucial difference, however, between the price of any other good that is pushed below that balancing point and interest rates being set below that point. If the price of hats, for example, is below the balancing point, the result is a shortage; that is, suppliers offer fewer hats than the number consumers are willing to buy at that price. Some consumers, therefore, will have to leave the market disappointed, without a hat in hand.

Central Bank-Caused Imbalances and Distortions

In contrast, in the market for borrowing and lending the Federal Reserve pushes interest rates below the point at which the market would have set them by increasing the supply of money on the loan market. Even though savers are not willing to supply more of their income for investors to borrow, the central bank provides the required funds by creating them out of thin air and making them available to banks for loans to investors. Investment spending now exceeds the amount of savings available to support the projects undertaken.

Investors who borrow the newly created money spend it to hire or purchase more resources, and their extra spending eventually starts putting upward pressure on prices. At the same time, more resources and workers are attracted to these new investment projects and away from other market activities.

The twin result of the Federal Reserve’s increase in the money supply, which pushes interest rates below that market-balancing point, is an emerging price inflation and an initial investment boom, both of which are unsustainable in the long run. Price inflation is unsustainable because it inescapably reduces the value of the money in everyone’s pockets, and threatens over time to undermine trust in the monetary system.

The boom is unsustainable because the imbalance between savings and investment will eventually necessitate a market correction when it is discovered that the resources available are not enough to produce all the consumer goods people want to buy, as well as all the investment projects borrowers have begun.

The unsustainability of such a monetary-induced investment boom has been shown, once again, to be true in the latest business cycle. Between 2003 and 2008, the Federal Reserve increased the money supply by at least 50 percent. Key interest rates, including the Federal Funds rate and the one-year Treasury yield, were either zero or negative for much of this time when adjusted for inflation. The rate on conventional mortgages, when inflation adjusted, was between two and four percent during this same period.

It is no wonder that there emerged the now infamous housing, investment, and consumer credit bubbles that have now burst. None of these would have been possible and sustainable for so long as they were if not for the Fed’s flood of money creation and the resulting zero or negative lending rates when adjusted for inflation.

The monetary expansion and the artificially low interest rates generated wide imbalances between investment and housing borrowing on the one hand and low levels of real savings in the economy on the other. It was inevitable that the reality of scarcity would finally catch up with all these mismatches between market supplies and demands.

This was, of course, exacerbated by the Federal government’s housing market creations, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. They opened their financial spigots through buying up or guaranteeing ever more home mortgages that were issued to a growing number of uncredit worthy borrowers. But the financial institutions that issued and then marketed those dubious mortgages were, themselves, only responding to the perverse incentives that had been created by the Federal Reserve and by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Why not extend more and more loans to questionable homebuyers when the money to fund them was virtually interest-free thanks to the Federal Reserve? And why not package them together and pass them on to others, when Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were subsidizing the risk on the basis of the “full faith and credit” of the United State government?

More Monetary Mischief in the Post-Bubble Era

What has been the Federal Reserve’s response in the face of the busted bubbles its own policies helped to create? Between September and December of 2008, the monetary base (currency in circulation and reserves in the banking system) exploded by 82 percent, from $905 billion to over $1.6 trillion. And over the last 12 months, from December 2008 to November 2009, the monetary base has continued to increase by an additional 18 percent to over $1.9 trillion.

At the same time, M-2 (currency in circulation plus demand and a variety of savings and time deposits) grew by 12 percent in calendar year 2008, and has continued to increase by 5 percent in 2009. Monetary aggregates like M-2 have not expanded even more in the last year due to the fact that about $1 trillion of the monetary base created by the Federal Reserve is sitting as excess reserves.

Why haven’t banks lent out this huge amount of newly created money? Partly it is due to the fact that after the wild bubble years, many financial institutions have returned to the more traditional credit worthy benchmarks for extending loans to potential borrowers. This has slowed down the approval rate for new loans. (For trying to once again follow some of these more responsible lending practices, President Obama has been criticizing the banks for failing to once more expand loans to potentially overly risky business and investment ventures.)

But more importantly, those excess reserves are collecting interest from the Federal Reserve. With continuing market uncertainties about government policies concerning environmental regulations, national health care costs, the burden of the Federal debt and other government unfunded liabilities (Social Security and Medicare), as well as other possible political interferences in the marketplace, banks have found it more attractive to be paid interest by the Federal Reserve rather than to lend money to private borrowers. And considering how low Fed policies have pushed down key market lending rates, leaving those excess reserves idle with Ben Bernanke has seemed the more profitable way of using all that lending power.

Even under the heavy-handed intervention of the government, markets are fundamentally resilient institutions that have the capacity to bounce back unless that governmental hand really chokes the competitive and profit-making life out of capitalism. Any real recovery in the private sector will result in increased demands to borrow that would be satisfied by all of that Fed-created funny money currently sitting idle. Once those hundreds of billions of dollars of excess reserves come flooding into the market, price inflation will not be far behind.

But even before the private sector may wish to significantly increase their demand to borrow to undertake new investment, the funding of the trillion-dollar a year Federal deficits may end up using a good part of those excess reserves. Then those hundreds of billions of Fed-created dollars will enter the market to finance all of the government’s spending that taxes are not paying for.

Central Banking as the Problem, Not the Solution

At the heart of the problem is that fact that the Federal Reserve’s manipulation of the money supply prevents interest rates from telling the truth: How much are people really choosing to save out of income, and therefore how much of the society’s resources – land, labor, capital – are really available to support sustainable investment activities in the longer run? What is the real cost of borrowing, independent of Fed distortions of interest rates, so businessmen could make realistic and fair estimates about which investment projects might be truly profitable, without the unnecessary risk of being drawn into unsustainable bubble ventures?

Unfortunately, as long as there are central banks, we will be the victims of the monetary central planners who have the monopoly power to control the amount of money and credit in the economy; manipulate interest rates by expanding or contracting bank reserves used for lending purposes; threaten the rollercoaster of business cycle booms and busts; and undermine the soundness of the monetary system through debasement of the currency and price inflation.

Interest rates, like market prices in general, cannot tell the truth about real supply and demand conditions when governments and their central banks prevent them from doing their job. All that government produces from their interventions, regulations and manipulations is false signals and bad information. And all of us suffer from this abridgement of our right to freedom of speech to talk honestly to each other through the competitive communication of market prices and interest rates, without governments and central banks getting in the way.


  1. "Arguing that there was no reason to fear significant price inflation for the foreseeable future"

    Since when can the Fed foresee the future?
    Did they foresee the housing crash, recession, and increasing unemployment?

    The crook says "I'm careful. I don't foresee going to jail".

    The player says "I'm careful, I don't foresee that my wife will find out".

    The Fed says, "We're careful, we don't foresee inflation or anything but good coming from our policies to print money now, then collect it back in the future".

  2. Great article that I full-heartedly agree with. One question about "...banks have found it more attractive to be paid interest by the Federal Reserve rather than to lend money to private borrowers"- aren't banks borrowing from the Fed at 0-0.25% and buying from the Treasury to get paid interest by them? I was under the impression they weren't loaning to the Fed but in fact borrowing for "free".

  3. I, too, thought what was stated above, that banks were not lending because of the spread between the Fed Funds Rate and T-Bills.

  4. Good article, but I'm amazed that no mention is made of the unproductive use of spending on the military and its adventures abroad. Social Security and Medicare are always cited as the problem, yet spending on defense (actually war) seems unassailable. When we get our priorities right?

  5. hypotetically if the Fed was abolished. Who or what would underpin the value of the currency? would we revert to a gold standard or a barter economy of some sort. is it possible to strip Fed of interest influencing ability, through money supply and base rates, and still keep the current currency regime. If we privitized money supply would not that open the market for private actors to print and market a number of private currencies that would replace the dollar. woudl this work>

  6. Excellent point, read The Exchange Artist by Jane Kamensky on America's first banking collapse. If you think all this hasn't happened before you're wrong.

    Fact is there are some bad actors out there and if they got a hold of the valuation of money, we would all be in trouble. Although, in today's world it would be a global issue.

  7. hey man this banking system of the world the central bank sort of the thing aim to correct discrepancies in the economy. If people save money and do not spend there is circular flow of income which is distorted with lots of cash balances held in pockets or spend on low supply products creating a mini loophole of money flow.But the problem with today's banking system is that when they do all their money creation stuff and lend to new businesses who spend on different sorts of infrastructure, the banks predict that these businness's products would appeal and consumers would reallocate the initial supply of money to them. But that is not the case in real life where again people start to save. As long as people do not produce something fruitful people are not willing to spend thus again there is a shortage of money in the economy.The circular flow is hampered. The answer to all this problem is some government control like taxes . But then capitalism says the opposite why should I spend on those commodities which I do not need. Well fair. Let us take the taxes out of the discussion and concentrate on money supply. There is one fact that if you get money for producing something you will produce it. But the circular flow problem creates unemployment in various unwanted sectors who do not have money to buy something which can be easily produced by economy. So people should be free to save their monetary resources and there should be money freely create ONLY to help people with buying products of high supply provided the economy has many competitors in the market and only those products are priced high whose supply curve reach a vertical stage after all people are willing to pay them.

  8. But the circular flow problem creates unemployment in various unwanted sectors who do not have money to buy something which can be easily produced by economy.

  9. You did really a great job. I found your blog very interesting and very informative. thanks for sharing.......

  10. hello, i would like to read more information about this topic because i think that is really interesting, besides, the post has very good informaton.

  11. You have a very good blog that the main thing a lot of interesting and useful!

  12. I usually don't comment on blogs but this blog inspired me to make one compliment as I know it's not enough for the meaningful context in your writing as one could understand it easily. Thanks for sharing.

  13. The way you shared your knowledge here is amazing!

  14. This is a great inspiring article. I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information.

    Facebook Fan Page

  15. This post is very excellent, because the very informative thanks for sharing. 

    Weight Loss Diet

  16. I agree with most of the points you make within this content.Click here

  17. Nice information. I have added this post to my blog. Hope you will post these kind of informative post more so we all can take benefit from these information...

  18. Wow, excellent data regarding this issue. You might want to let me know how long will it take? Because I like to write the thesis or may be it would be nice to detect the thesis writing service. Thank you very much.
    Real Estate Logo Design

  19. Wow, excellent data regarding this issue. You might want to let me know how long will it take? Because I like to write the thesis or may be it would be nice to detect the thesis writing service. Thank you very much.
    Logo Design Blog

  20. I really enjoy reading your posts as I learn a lot from them. I also broaden my thinking as far as what I can use and do with things

  21. Very interesting Post, looking forward to reading more from you

  22. Thanks for this article. It's just what I was searching for. I am always interested in this subject.

  23. There Is Obviously a lot to know about this. I suppose you made Some Great points in the Feature also.

  24. Thanks for the article! Very informative!
    Cheap Essays

  25. Thanks for sharing your website.This blogs are very informative. I really say thanks to you. Cheap Essay Writing

  26. Thanks for an interesting article. After looking through different websites I finally found something worth reading. Paper Writing Services

  27. Buy Vine MarketingAugust 21, 2013 at 1:17 AM

    Your post is awesome. That is a wonderful insight on the subject and I would like to thank you for sharing. Buy Vine Marketing

  28. Nice article, I am a big time fan of your site, keep up the nice work

  29. Excellent site you have got here.. It’s difficult to find high quality writing like yours nowadays. I truly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

  30. Exciting blog post. I really like the content and information you posted here in this blog.

  31. Nice blog to know about the market based interest rates.This would be useful to share market business people.
    Magento Experts India | Magento Developers India

  32. I really liked your blog! It helped me alot¡¬ Awesome. Exactly what I was looking for. Thanks!

  33. I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it thankz
    Airport Taxi

  34. International writing services are great techinqe to develop your business and if nay buddy need unique versatility of writing service visit a research paper for college | term papers for sale

  35. Happy to see this, I am happy to find this great Blog.

  36. Nice post, I bookmark your blog because I found very good information on your blog, Thanks for sharing more information. YTZ Airport Taxi
    YTZ Airport Limousine
    Billy Bishop Airport
    Taxi to Billy Bishop Airport
    Limo to Billy Bishop Airport

  37. I was about to say something on this topic. But now i can see that everything on this topic is very amazing and mind blowing, so i have nothing to say here. I am just going through all the topics and being appreciated. Thanks for sharing..

  38. Great post....Thank you for posting the great content……I found it quiet interesting, hopefully you will keep posting such blogs…
    If you Want more Click this link

  39. I am glad to see that people are actually writing about this issue in such a smart way, showing us all different sides to it. Thanks for sharing, please keep it up.

    Also checkout our Pictures of happy new year 2017 new collections.